Measles, Social Media, and Contrived Statistics

The all-caps, multi-colored claim fills the social media page.

Anti-vaccine activist and author of the claim, Nicolas Hulscher, peers ominously through the print. A new post is making the rounds this week, and it’s the latest from Hulscher.

Hulscher first broke his story in February on LindellTV, hosted by that famous science expert, the My Pillow guy.

Hulscher’s claim: according to the CDC’s “own data”, the measles vaccine is far deadlier than the actual measles.

Hulscher cites the CDC website VAERS, a site for self-reporting adverse vaccine reactions.

VAERS was never meant to be taken as fact, as evidence, or as a verified study of ANY kind. It’s a public forum.

Anyone can report: Individuals. Parents.  Vaccine deniers and conspiracists.

All anonymous and unverified.

My puppy Jolene could file a report if only she had opposable thumbs.

From the CDC’s VAERS report, Hulscher constructs a terrifying three-decades-long graph. Over three decades, VAERS reports 193 deaths due to the vaccine, but only seven deaths from measles in the same time span.

That’s a whopping 2,657% higher count of vaccine deaths compared to measles deaths!! Sound the alarm! Hulscher even discounts the measles deaths because malpracticing doctors didn’t employ (unsubstantiated) cures like “cod liver oil and vitamin A.”

“Vaccines kill!” Hulscher declared on the My Pillow show.

The American Academy of Pediatrics and five decades of peer-reviewed research disagree: the MMR vaccine is, and continues to be, safe and effective.

Measles is not simply a rite of passage, NBD childhood sniffles. Measles brings a risk of brain inflammation, serious respiratory complications, as well as degenerative central nervous system disease years after infection.

Twenty-six years ago, measles was declared eliminated in the United States.

Tragically, we will likely lose elimination status this week. As I write, an international panel of experts is meeting to determine our status.

Pseudoscience and conspiracies are attractive because like Hulscher, they offer certainty. They offer Gnostic-like insider information not available to the rest of us.

Actual science requires controlled studies, peer-review, and consensus of evidence.

Too many of us want the easy answer.

Jolene, dreaming of opposable thumbs.

NUMBER ONE

In a perfect world, there would be no mistakes. But the world is not perfect, and mistakes – sometimes deadly – happen.

In mid-2018, two nurses in the island country of Samoa accidently reconstituted the measles vaccine with a muscle relaxant instead of water. Two infants died.

The Samoan government paused vaccinations to investigate the deaths. Within weeks, the error was discovered. But in a country with a measles vaccination rate already lower than recommended for herd immunity, parental fear spells disaster. 

That sound you hear? 

That’s the anti-vaccine cavalry riding in, led by Robert F. Kennedy, Jr., President-elect Donald Trump’s nominee to be the Secretary of Health and Human Services. 

In 2019, RFK Jr. arrived in Samoa with his anti-vaccine message, embracing local anti-vaccine proponents. Months of parental fears stoked by RFK’s antivaccine message led to disaster: vaccination rates plummeted.

Three months after RFK’s visit, Samoa experienced a devastating measles outbreak. The government took action – mandating shutdowns and vaccinations. 

In 2019, there were almost 3,000 measles cases reported in Samoa. Thirty-nine people died, thirty-five of them children. 

RFK Jr. never updated his antivax website, Children’s Health Defense, regarding the cause of the original deaths. RFK Jr. denies his influence on the deadly outbreak.

RFK Jr. sometimes tries to back away from his antivax hot takes, like when he said Ann Frank had more freedom than people under vaccine mandates. Still, in a CNN interview just a year ago, RFK Jr. bragged about telling random parents with a baby “better not get him vaccinated,” in order to “save” the child. 

RFK Jr. has a long history of promoting health-related conspiracies:

HIV doesn’t cause AIDS. MMR vaccine causes autism. Chemtrails. Drinking raw milk is harmless. Chemicals in water are causing kids to be trans. COVID-19 was ethnically targeted to avoid infecting Jewish and Chinese people. 5G high speed internet harvests our data and controls our behavior. Fluoride in the water supply is harmful.

RFK Jr. is not a doctor or any type of healthcare professional, an epidemiologist, or a public health policy expert. 

I don’t know if RFK Jr. will be confirmed to lead Health and Human Services, but I DO know this: 

He was the number one choice of the president-elect.

First in line.

Only the best people, he promised. Only the best.